CAPM-based capital budgeting and nonadditivity
نویسنده
چکیده
This paper deals with the CAPM-derived capital budgeting criterion, and in particular with Rubinstein’s (1973) criterion, according to which a project is profitable if the project rate of return is greater than the risk-adjusted cost of capital, where the latter depends on the project’s disequilibrium systematic risk. It is shown that the disequilibrium net present value implied by this criterion, widely used in corporate finance, is nonadditive. Four proofs are provided: (i) a counterexample taken from Copeland and Weston (1988), (ii) a modus-tollens argument showing that this notion of NPV is incompatible with additivity, (iii) a formalization showing that this NPV does not fulfil the principle of description invariance (iv) an example showing that CAPMminded evaluators may incur arbitrage losses. The disequilibrium NPV should therefore be dismissed in investment decisions and valuations. Running Title. CAPM-based capital budgeting and nonadditivity
منابع مشابه
Correct or incorrect application of CAPM? Correct or incorrect decisions with CAPM?
This paper focuses on inconsistencies arising from the use of NPV and CAPM for capital budgeting. It shows that (i) CAPM capital budgeting decision-making based on disequilibrium NPV is deductively inferred by the Capital Asset Pricing Model, (ii) the use of the disequilibrium NPV is widespread in finance both as a decision rule and as a valuation tool, (iii) the disequilibrium NPV does not gua...
متن کاملCAPM for estimating the cost of equity capital Interpreting the empirical evidence
We argue that the empirical evidence against the capital asset pricing model (CAPM) based on stock returns does not invalidate its use for estimating the cost of capital for projects in making capital budgeting decisions. Because stocks are backed not only by projects in place, but also by the options to modify current projects and undertake new ones, the expected returns on stocks need not sat...
متن کاملStock Exchange Listing Induces Sophistication of Capital Budgeting
This article compares capital budgeting techniques employed in listed and unlisted companies in Brazil. We surveyed the Chief Financial Officers (CFOs) of 398 listed companies and 300 large unlisted companies, and based on 91 respondents, the results suggest that the CFOs of listed companies tend to use less simplistic methods more often, for example: NPV and CAPM, and that CFOs of unlisted com...
متن کاملEstimating the Cost of Capital Through Time: An Analysis of the Sources of Error
practitioners needing estimates of a firm's equity cost of capital have long relied on the Capital Asset Pricing Model (CAPM). Recent evidence casts renewed doubt on the validity of the CAPM and beta. However, there is not much evidence to gauge the importance of the rejections of the CAPM in a practical decision-making context. This paper presents evidence on the sources of error in estimating...
متن کاملEssays on Corporate Investment
In an asset-pricing model calibrated to match the standard asset pricing empirical properties –in particular, the time-variation in the equity premium – we calculate the welfare (value) implications of sub-optimal capital budgeting decisions. Specifically, we calculate that an investment policy that ignores the timevariation in the equity premium, such as would occur with a cost of capital foll...
متن کامل